Consumer Reports just announced that they can’t recommend the iPhone 4 after they ran a number of tests to confirm the iPhone 4’s signal problems. Of course, if you don’t mind owning a phone that drops calls if you hold it wrong, they still placed it on top of their smartphone ratings (subscription required) anyway, thanks to the “sharpest display and best video camera” they’ve seen on any phone, as well as the iPhone 4’s battery life and gyroscope.
The iPhone 4’s signal problems aren’t a mystery anymore, but here’s what we’ve learned from the Consumer Reports’ lab test:
- Contrary to what Apple says, other AT&T phones didn’t have a signal loss problem–at least not to this extent. They also tested the iPhone 3GS and Palm Pre the same way they ran the iPhone 4 tests.
- Apple’s claim that the signal problems were due to a graphics error or faulty software that “mistakenly displays 2 more bars than it should” is questionable. Also, we don’t think anyone bought into that explanation.
- According to the report, AT&T’s network “might not be the primary suspect.” They’re apparently giving away free 3G MicroCells to keep you signed with them anyway. So just take it if you’ve been offered one.
And, as a last note: if you’re stuck with a shiny new iPhone 4 and you don’t want to get a $29 bumper to ‘fix’ the signal situation, they’re suggesting you use non-conductive tape to cover the corner. It might not be the most attractive solution around, but it won’t cost $29. Of course, you can always Steve Jobs’ advice and just don’t hold it that way.
Tags: Antennagate, Consumer Reports, iPhone, iPhone 4, Mobile Phones
